Forest and Wood Products

Forest and Wood Products

Editor's Note Reviewer Performance and Contributions to the Journal of Forest and Wood Products (2012–2026)

Author
Department of Wood and Paper Science and Technology, Faculty of Natural Resources, University College of Agriculture and Natural Resources, University of Tehran, Karaj, Iran.
10.22059/jfwp.2026.109931
Abstract
Because of the significant role of reviewers in improving the quality of published articles, a brief report on reviewers’ performance and contributions to the Journal of Forest and Wood Products from 2012 to the present is provided here. The list of the journal’s reviewers is published annually and is available for viewing on the journal’s website. For each submission, the associate editor proposes reviewers with appropriate expertise in the subject matter, and the editor-in-chief makes the final selection of qualified reviewers. While scientific and specialized competence as well as the absence of conflict of interest are key criteria in the selection process, reviewers are also expected to adhere to ethical principles throughout the review process. Examples of violations of professional ethical standards during the peer-review process include: failing to maintain confidentiality in peer review, misappropriation of ideas and methods, or findings of a manuscript for personal interests prior to its publication, acceptance of review invitation despite a conflict of interest or a lack of sufficient expertise, unauthorized delegation of peer review and abusive and disrespectful reviewer comments. Since the reviewer is responsible for review, uploading all or part of the manuscript into artificial intelligence (AI) tools or using AI to generate a review report is a violation of ethical standards. Since the peer review process in this journal is double-blind, attempting to identify the author is not permitted. Researchers from over 30 universities and scientific and research institutions serve as reviewers for this journal. During the mentioned period, 889 articles were reviewed. In the first five years, the average review duration was 25 days, but in the last ten years, the duration has decreased to 13 days. Some reviewers fail to respond to the review invitation which leads to delays in the review process. During the specified period, 944 review invitation went unanswered. Therefore, reviewers are kindly requested to indicate their acceptance or declination of review invitations as soon as possible. We sincerely appreciate the valuable and responsible contributions of all the reviewers to this journal.